Chiariello & Chiariello

Guide To New York Real Estate Partition Actions

Experienced Legal Support Helping You Settle Disputes


Owning real estate in New York State can be both a rewarding investment and a source of complex legal issues. Co-ownership is a common occurrence, whether it arises from inheritance, marriage, or other circumstances. While co-ownership allows for shared investments, it can also lead to disputes, especially when one co-owner wishes to sell the property while the other does not. In such common situations, New York real estate law provides a legal remedy known as a partition action. At Chiariello & Chiariello, our experienced team of attorneys is here to help you navigate the intricacies of real estate partition actions in Long Island, NY and protect your interests.

What Is A Real Estate Partition Action in New York State?

Partition actions serve as a legal mechanism to resolve disputes between co-owners when they cannot reach an agreement on the future of a property. In New York, there are two types of partition actions, physical property divides and legal property divides, read on to understand the difference between these two.

Contact our attorneys at Chiariello & Chiariello if you need help with a dispute right away.
Give us a call at 516-360-2869
or contact us online.

Frequently Asked Questions About Partition Actions


How Do Physical Property Divides Work?

When it's feasible to physically divide the property, the court may opt for this approach. For example, if a property consists of six lots, the court can split it into two separate properties, each owned by one of the co-owners. This allows the co-owners the freedom to do as they wish with their respective portions.

How Do Legal Property Divides Work?

In cases where the property cannot be physically divided, a voluntary partition may be initiated. This allows a co-owner to sell their share to an outside party. While this is common among investors, it can be more complex when family members are involved, as objections to sharing ownership with outsiders may arise.

What's The Process of a Partition Action?

A partition action involves taking the dispute to court. Typically, the judge's most common decision is to order the sale of the property, with the proceeds divided equally between the co-owners. Alternatively, co-owners can choose to sell the property voluntarily without going to court, provided they have a well-drafted settlement agreement in place.


Important Considerations

While the concept of partition actions may seem straightforward, they involve intricate legal processes with specific requirements. Mistakes can be costly. Additionally, individual circumstances can greatly impact the outcome of a partition action. For instance, if one co-owner resides on the property while the other does not, the resident co-owner cannot block the sale and may be required to vacate the premises.

Recent legislation in New York has introduced protections for homeowners facing partition actions, such as requiring sales on the open market, mandatory mediation, and the right of first refusal for "holdouts" who wish to retain their ownership.

Chiariello & Chiariello in Glen Cove NY

Why Choose Chiariello & Chiariello in Long Island, NY

Partition actions can be legally complex and emotionally charged, particularly when family is involved. At Chiariello & Chiariello, our seasoned real estate attorneys possess the expertise to navigate these challenges on your behalf. We are dedicated to protecting your rights and ensuring a fair resolution in your partition action case. Our commitment to excellence and comprehensive understanding of New York real estate law sets us apart.

About Us


  • Serving the Community for Over 50 Years
    Our firm has helped Nassau county residents with their legal matters for more than five decades.
  • Honest Legal Counsel
    At Chiariello & Chiariello, we pride ourselves on integrity and providing clients with straightforward advice.
  • Family-Owned Law Office
    Our firm has been in the family for over 50 years and we look to treat all of our clients as part of our family.
  • Small Firm Attention, Big Firm Results
    Our attorneys pursue maximum compensation for our clients while providing them with highly personalized attention throughout the entire process.

Standing By You Every Step of the Way


If you are experiencing hardship in your life due to another’s negligence, working with a skilled and knowledgeable legal team can make all the difference in improving your situation — and helping you get your life back on track.

Start with a Free Consultation

Client Reviews

Every Case Matters To Us


"They demonstrated commitment to my case, which allowed me to trust that he was advocating for my best interests."

- Liz, Former Client

"Treated like family. Passionate, caring, honest and professional. Always kept in contact with us through every step for 2 years. Amazing lawyers, who now we call friends!"

- Jackie, Former Client

"I went to them when I was turned away from a big firm who didn’t want to help me. This firm won my case and got me a settlement that surpassed my expectations!"

- Peter, Former Client

At Chiariello & Chiariello, You're Family

Start With a Free Consultation Today