Chiariello & Chiariello

Apr 30, 2024

Navigating landlord and tenant disputes in Long Island, NY, can be a complex and stressful ordeal, given the intricate nature of New York housing laws. Whether you’re a tenant facing unjust treatment or a landlord dealing with lease violations, understanding your legal rights and obligations is crucial. At Chiariello & Chiariello, we specialize in providing legal guidance to both landlords and tenants, ensuring that each party can resolve their disputes fairly and lawfully. This blog post explores common questions related to landlord and tenant disputes and offers insights into when and why legal representation is essential.

In What Situations Would Someone Need To Hire A Lawyer for a Landlord and Tenant Dispute?

Hiring a lawyer for a landlord and tenant dispute is advisable when:

  1. Eviction Proceedings: If a landlord is seeking to evict a tenant, or if a tenant is facing eviction.
  2. Lease Disagreements: Disputes over terms in the lease, such as rent, maintenance, and lease duration.
  3. Property Damage Claims: When there is a disagreement over who is responsible for property damage.
  4. Security Deposit Recovery: If a tenant is having trouble recovering their security deposit.
  5. Illegal Unit or Rent Issues: In cases where a tenant suspects the rental unit is illegal, or if there are disputes over rent stabilization or control.

These situations often require legal expertise to navigate the complex landlord-tenant laws and ensure that the actions taken are lawful and fair.

What are Probable Reasons to Sue My Landlord in New York?

Tenants might find themselves needing to sue their landlord for several reasons, including:

  • Failure to Maintain: Landlords in New York are required to keep rental properties habitable, according to state and local housing codes.
  • Illegal Eviction Attempts: Such as changing locks or shutting off utilities to force a tenant out.
  • Overcharged Rent: Especially relevant in rent-controlled or stabilized units where there are strict regulations about how much rent can be charged.
  • Violation of Lease Terms: When landlords do not follow the terms set out in the lease agreement.
  • Security Deposit Mismanagement: Including withholding a security deposit illegally after a tenant moves out.

These are valid grounds for a tenant to seek legal redress, which can involve filing a lawsuit against the landlord to resolve these issues.

Can a Landlord Sue a Tenant?

Yes, landlords can also initiate lawsuits against tenants. Common reasons include:

  • Non-payment of Rent: If a tenant fails to pay rent, landlords can sue to recover the owed amounts and potentially evict the tenant.
  • Damage to Property: Landlords can seek compensation for damages that go beyond normal wear and tear.
  • Breach of Lease: If a tenant violates terms of the lease agreement, such as subletting without permission or using the property for illegal activities.
  • Holding Over: When a tenant refuses to leave after their lease has ended or has been terminated properly according to legal procedures.

Landlords must follow legal proceedings to address these issues, often necessitating professional legal assistance.

What Are Renters’ Rights in New York?

Renters in New York have significant rights, which include:

  • Right to a Habitable Home: All rental units must be safe and livable, meeting all health and safety codes.
  • Right to Privacy: Landlords must provide notice before entering a tenant’s rental unit, except in emergencies.
  • Protection from Discrimination: Tenants are protected under federal and state laws from discrimination based on race, religion, nationality, gender, family status, or disability.
  • Right to Organize: Tenants have the right to organize and form tenants’ unions without fear of harassment or retaliation from landlords.

Understanding these rights is fundamental for tenants to ensure they are not exploited or treated unfairly by their landlords.

For residents of Long Island, navigating the landscape of landlord and tenant disputes can be daunting. Whether you’re a landlord or a tenant, Chiariello & Chiariello is here to help you understand your legal rights and obligations and to provide robust representation if legal action becomes necessary. Contact us for more detailed guidance tailored to your specific situation.